Wild Avril Lavigne Doppelganger Theory That Just Won’t Die (5 of 8)

They argue that tracks like “My Happy Ending” and “Nobody’s Home” weren’t just moody teenage heartbreak songs—they were hidden messages from Melissa, the clone, the decoy, the prisoner in Avril’s skin. Some even believe that Avril’s red carpet poses look “unnatural” now as if she’s mimicking someone else’s identity. Not a decade of growth and evolution, of course—no, it must be Melissa.

To her credit, Avril has responded to this absurd theory with humor. In 2017, a fan directly questioned Avril on Facebook about her death, and she responded with humor. “Nope, I’m still here,” she replied before suggesting people have far too much time on their hands. Honestly? Based answer.