Lost Paradises: 8 Secret Islands You Can Rent All For Yourself (2 of 5)

Eilean Sionnach, Isle of Skye

Just a tiny island with giant vibes. Eilean Sionnach gives you the whole lighthouse cottage and the island around it all to yourself. In 2023, the Times magazine gave this private retreat a huge shout-out, calling it one of Scotland’s best places to stay. With all the gorgeous views and blissful solitude, it’s easy to understand why. Getting to the lighthouse might be a little tricky physically, as it requires walking over slippery rocks, but hey, who doesn’t like a little adventure every once in a while? From £395 per night, it’s the perfect mix of cozy, cinematic, and gloriously disconnected. Bring your camera, your boots, and a lot of books.

Prince Island, Belize

Just off San Pedro, this eight-acre private retreat is reached via a short flight from Belize City, plus a 30-minute boat ride. It can fit up to 18 adults and four kids, so a big family vacation would be perfect here. The heart of the island is a social hub with an infinity pool, shaded lounges, and a pool table. Rates are individual but always more than you’d think. Because of that, the all-inclusive package is a must: private-chef gourmet meals, curated cocktails, daily housekeeping, and fun excursions—you’ll get all this and more.